Administered by the ITA
June 7, 2012
| Team | ||
| Rank | School | |
| 1 | Emory | |
| 2 | Johns Hopkins | |
| 3 | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 4 | NC Wesleyan | |
| 5 | Washington and Lee | |
| 6 | Mary Washington | |
| 7 | Swarthmore | |
| 8 | Haverford | |
| 9 | Franklin and Marshall | |
| 10 | Christopher Newport | |
| 11 | Washington College | |
| 12 | Rhodes | |
| 13 | Mississippi College | |
| 14 | Methodist | |
| 15 | Birmingham Southern | |
| Singles | ||
| Rank | Player | School |
| 1 | Dillon Pottish | Emory |
| 2 | Eric Shulman | Christopher Newport |
| 3 | Andy Hersh | Johns Hopkins |
| 4 | Tanner Brown | Johns Hopkins |
| 5 | Rinat Khussainoy | North Carolina Wesleyan |
| 6 | Hayden White | Washington and Lee |
| 7 | Robert Kjellberg | Christopher Newport |
| 8 | Duke Miller | Carnegie Mellon |
| 9 | Chris Goodwin | Emory |
| 10 | Ben Hwang | Johns Hopkins |
| 11 | Kevin Caulfield | Haverford |
| 12 | Ross Silverberg | Franklin and Marshall |
| 13 | Alex Blakhin | Mary Washington |
| 14 | Christian Secord | Carnegie Mellon |
| 15 | Ian Wagner | Emory |
| Doubles | ||
| Rank | Player | School |
| 1 | Duncan/Miller | CMU |
| 2 | Elgort/Barnaby | Johns Hopkins |
| 3 | Donato/Rizzolo | Mary Washington |
| 4 | Rumyantsev/Kjellberg | North Carolina Weslyan |
| 5 | King/Shulman | Christopher Newport |
| 6 | Barnas/Albers | Salisbury |
| 7 | Wooten/Branning | Mississippi |
| 8 | Slevin/Erhardt | Rhodes |
| 9 | Humphreys/Goodwin | Emory |
| 10 | Silverberg/MacArthur | Franklin Marshall |
