Administered by the ITA
April 12, 2012
| Team | ||
| Rank | School | |
| 1 | Kenyon College | |
| 2 | Washington University | |
| 3 | Case Western Reserve University | |
| 4 | Gustavus Adolphus College | |
| 5 | Denison University | |
| 6 | University of Chicago | |
| 7 | Kalamazoo College | |
| 8 | DePauw University | |
| 9 | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater | |
| 10 | Carleton College | |
| 11 | St Olaf College | |
| 12 | Luther College | |
| 13 | Elmhurst College | |
| 14 | Wheaton | |
| 15 | Grinnell College | |
| 16 | Carthage College | |
| 17 | Coe College | |
| 18 | St Thomas University | |
| Singles | ||
| Rank | Player | School |
| 1 | Adam Putterman | Washington University |
| 2 | Amrik Donkena | Gustavus Adolphus |
| 3 | Paul Burgin | Kenyon College |
| 4 | Michael Razumousky | Kenyon College |
| 5 | Sam Miles | DePauw University |
| 6 | Will Drougas | Case Western Reserve |
| 7 | Tom Cawood | Denison University |
| 8 | Fabrico Moncada | St John's University |
| 9 | Scott Sundstrom | Luther College |
| 10 | Mya Smith-Dennis | Gustavus Adolphus University |
| 11 | Ryan Kreis | Lake Forest College |
| 12 | Nate Eddy | Kalamazoo College |
| 13 | CJ Williams | Kenyon College |
| 14 | Patrick Cole | Allegheny College |
| 15 | Jeff Lotz | Carthage College |
| 16 | Mark Denenfeld | Kalamazoo College |
| 17 | Troy Brinker | University of Chicago |
| 18 | Alex Harbert | Elmhurst College |
| 19 | Victor Khristenko | Coe College |
| 19 | Brian McCarthy | University of St Thomas |
| 20 | Nick Garcia | Dubuque University |
| 21 | Chris Kuna | University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| 22 | Nick Piotrowski | University of Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| 23 | Andrew Hwang | Carleton College |
| 24 | Byron Balkin | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 25 | Ben Koepecky | DePauw University |
| 26 | Jan Stefanski | University of Chicago |
| 26 | Gary Parizher | Washington University |
| Doubles | ||
| Rank | Team | School |
| 1 | Amrik Donkena/Mya Smith-Dennis | Gustavus Adolphus |
| 2 | John Healey/Kyle Gerber | Case Western Reserve |
| 3 | Adam Putterman/Ross Putterman | Washington University |
| 4 | Jeff Lotz/Daneric Hazelman | Carthage College |
| 5 | Troy Brinker/Jan Stefanski | University of Chicago |
| 6 | Tyler Cempre/Matt McErlean | Denison University |
| 7 | Nate Eddy/Mark Denenfeld | Kalamazoo College |
| 8 | Austin Griffin/Josh Stiles | Kenyon College |
| 9 | Michael Razumuovsky/CJ Williams | Kenyon College |
| 10 | Joey Frank/Mike Kathary | Ohio Northern University |
| 11 | Curtis Newman/Noah Sprinkel | Coe College |
| 12 | Byron Balkin/Mitch Osborne | University of Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| 13 | Sam Miles/Ben Kopecky | DePauw University |
| 14 | Bobby Brooks/Kevin Lewis | University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| 15 | John Wright/Andy Cantina | St Olaf College |
| 16 | Scott Sundstrom/Ramesh Kharki | Luther College |
| 17 | Alex Habert/Will Jung | Elmhurst College |
| 18 | Mike Lunka/Bobby Steingraeber | St Mary's University |
| 19 | Nick Garcia/Andrew Sheedy | University of Dubuque |
