A player must meet any of the following criteria to earn ITA All-America honors:
Singles
Finish in the Top 20 of the final ITA Rankings
Doubles
Finish in the Top 10 of the final ITA Rankings
| MEN | WOMEN | |||||
| Name | School | S/D | Name | School | S/D | |
| Hans Hach | Abilene Christian | S/D | Micah Hermsdorf | Abilene Christian | D | |
| Nick Plum | Abilene Christian | D | Hannah Kelley | Abilene Christian | D | |
| Eudaldo Bonet | Armstrong Atlantic | S | Julia Mongin | Abilene Christian | S | |
| Mikk Irdoja | Armstrong Atlantic | S/D | Aleksandra Filipovski | Armstrong Atlantic | S/D | |
| Matus Mydla | Armstrong Atlantic | S | Marlen Hacke | Armstrong Atlantic | D | |
| Georgi Rumenov | Armstrong Atlantic | S/D | Kathleen Henry | Armstrong Atlantic | S | |
| Bernardo Fernandes | Augusta State | S | Barbora Kritickova | Armstrong Atlantic | S/D | |
| Marco Mokrzycki | Barry | S/D | Olga Kalodzitsa | Armstrong Atlantic | S/D | |
| Fabian Groetsch | Barry | S | Linda Fritschken | Barry | S | |
| Leonel Vivas | Barry | D | Mona Mansour | Barry | D | |
| Daniele Piludu | Concordia (NY) | S | Cristina Vallardes | Barry | S/D | |
| Alex Caspari | Francis Marion | S/D | Annie Hwang | BYU-Hawaii | S/D | |
| Gavin Davison | Francis Marion | D | Yuan Jia | BYU-Hawaii | S/D | |
| Jerome Leborgne | Georgia College | D | Sherry Liu | BYU-Hawaii | S/D | |
| Johan Wadstein | Georgia College | D | Marietta Tuionetoa | BYU-Hawaii | D | |
| Patric Guenther | Hawaii Pacific | D | Martina Rubesova | California (PA) | S/D | |
| Petr Michnev | Hawaii Pacific | S/D | Franziska Steinhardt | California (PA) | D | |
| Paul-Henri Arrigoni | Lander | S | Christie Lau | Cal State LA | S | |
| Vlad Cirla | Lynn | S/D | Paola Cigui | Columbus State | S/D | |
| Willi Wolfer | Lynn | S/D | Milica Tomic | Columbus State | D | |
| Ricardo Campos | New Orleans | D | Madga Riutort | Florida Southern | S | |
| Hossam Meligy | New Orleans | D | Mona Blauen | Francis Marion | D | |
| Jason Alabaster | Rollins | D | Jitka Gavdunova | Francis Marion | S/D | |
| Lucas Jovita | Rollins | S/D | Zora Vlckova | Hawaii Pacific | S | |
| Jeff Morris | Rollins | S | Ioana Ivan | Lynn | S/D | |
| Attila Toth | Queens (NY) | S | Sabine Krause | Lynn | S/D | |
| Christian Hansen | Valdosta State | S | Alexandra Johannson | Nova Southeastern | S | |
| Kevin Ducros | West Florida | S/D | Laura Kemkes | Saint Leo | S | |
| Bruno Savi | West Florida | S/D |
