A player must meet any of the following criteria to earn ITA All-America honors:
Singles
1.) Top 16 seed in NCAA Singles Championships, or;
2.) Reach round of 16 in NCAA Singles Championships, or;
3.) Finish in the Top 20 of the final ITA Rankings.
Doubles
1.) Top eight seed in NCAA Doubles Championships, or;
2.) Reach quarterfinals of NCAA Doubles Championship, or;
3.) Finish in Top 10 of final ITA Rankings
2009 ITA Men's All-America Team
Division I Men's Tennis(S - Singles, D - Doubles)
| Bruno Agostinelli | Kentucky (S) |
| Omar Altmann | Pepperdine (S, D) |
| Jean-Yves Aubone | Florida State (S) |
| Bassam Beidas | Pepperdine (D) |
| Jonas Berg | Mississippi (S, D) |
| Devin Britton | Mississippi (S) |
| Arnau Brugues | Tulsa (S) |
| Alex Clayton | Stanford (S) |
| Clay Donato | North Carolina (D) |
| Robert Farah | USC (S, D) |
| Taylor Fogleman | North Carolina (D) |
| Steven Forman | Wake Forest (D) |
| Guillermo Gomez | Georgia Tech (S) |
| Jamie Hunt | Georgia (D) |
| Dominic Inglot | Virginia (S, D) |
| Dean Jackson | San Diego (S) |
| Steve Johnson, | USC (S, D) |
| Bryan Koniecko | Ohio State (S) |
| Austin Krajicek | Texas A&M (D) |
| Dimitar Kutrovsky | Texas (S) |
| Denes Lukacs | Baylor (S) |
| Steven Moneke | Ohio State (S) |
| Oleksandr Nedovyesov | Oklahoma State (S) |
| Cory Parr | Wake Forest (S, D) |
| John-Patrick Smith | Tennessee (S, D) |
| Conor Pollock | Texas A&M (S,D) |
| Tim Puetz | Auburn (D) |
| Bruno Rosa | Rice (S) |
| Davey Sandgren | Tennessee (D) |
| Nate Schnugg | Georgia (S, D) |
| Sanam Singh | Virginia (S) |
| Michael Shabaz | Virginia (D) |
| Neal Skupski | LSU (D) |
| Blake Strode | Arkansas (S) |
| Bram ten Berge | Mississippi (D) |
| Alexey Tysrenov | Auburn (D) |
| Daniel Vallverdu | Miami (S) |
| Michael Venus | LSU (S, D) |
| Jay Weinacker | NC State (S) |
