| 2011 | Maria Sanchez | USC |
| 2010 | Caitlin Whoriskey | Tennessee |
| 2009 | Kelcy Tefft | Notre Dame |
| 2008 | Riza Zaladeda | UCLA |
| 2007 | Jenna Long | North Carolina |
| 2006 | Amber Liu | Stanford |
| 2005 | Megan Bradley | Miami |
| 2004 | Raquel Kops-Jones | California |
| 2003 | Vilmarie Castellv | Tennessee |
| 2002 | Jessica Lehnhoff | Florida |
| 2001 | Michelle Dasso | Notre Dame |
| 2000 | Zuzana Lesenarova | San Diego |
| 1999 | Vanessa Webb | Duke |
| 1998 | Lauren Nikolaus | William & Mary |
| 1997 | Melissa Zimpfer | Wisconsin |
| 1996 | Keri Phebus | UCLA |
| 1995 | Kelly Pace | Texas |
| 1994 | Angela Lettiere | Georgia |
| 1993 | Heather Willens | Stanford |
| 1992 | Shannan McCarthy | Georgia |
| 1991 | Nicole Arendt | Florida |
| 1990 | Stacey Schefflin | Georgia |
| 1989 | Jennifer Santrock | SMU |
| 1988 | Ronni Reis | Miami |
| 1987 | Patty Fendick | Stanford |
| 1986 | Gretchen Rush | Trinity (TX) |
| 1985 | Linda Gates | Stanford |
| 1984 | Kathleen Cummings | Texas |


