| 2010 | Hilary Barte/Mallory Burdette | Stanford |
| 2009 | Natalie Pluskota/Caitlin Whoriskey | Tennessee |
| 2008 | Amanda McDowell/Irina Falconi | Georgia Tech |
| 2007 | Caitlin Whoriskey/Zsofia Zubor | Tennessee |
| 2006 | Roxanne Clarke/Kady Pooler | Arizona State |
| 2005 | Catrina Thompson/Christian Thompson | Notre Dame |
| 2004 | Whitney Benik/Lolita Frangulyan | Florida |
| 2003 | Kelly Schmandt/Aleke Tsoubanos | Vanderbilt |
| 2002 | Sarah Riske/Aleke Tsoubanos | Vanderbilt |
| 2001 | Lindsay Dawaf/Jessica Lehnhoff | Florida |
| 2000 | Lauren Kalvaria/Gabriela Lastra | Stanford |
| 1999 | Zuzana Lesenarova/Katarina Valykova | San Diego |
| 1998 | Teryn Ashley/Marissa Irvin | Stanford |
| 1997 | Zsofia Csapo/Angela Lawrence | Pepperdine |
| 1996 | Farley Taylor/Cristina Moros | Texas |
| 1995 | Amanda Augustus/Renata Kolbovic | California |
| 1994 | Monica Mraz/Wendy Lyons | Duke |
| 1993 | Pam Nelson/Keirsten Alley | California |
| 1992 | Laxmi Poruri/Heather Willens | Stanford |
| 1991 | Susan Gilchrist/Vickie Paynter | Texas |
| 1990 | Sandra Birch/Debbie Graham | Stanford |
| 1989 | Meredith McGrath/Teri Whitlinger | Stanford |
| 1988 | Kelly Mulvihill/Stephanie Reese | Indiana |


