| 2011 | Vahid Merzadeh | Florida State |
| 2010 | Jason Jung | Michigan |
| 2009 | Blake Strode | Arkansas |
| 2008 | Lars Poerschke | Baylor |
| 2007 | Danny Bryan | Louisiana State |
| 2006 | Jonathan Stokke | Duke |
| 2005 | Mat Cloer | Florida State |
| 2004 | Lee Taylor Walker | Memphis |
| 2003 | Trevor Smith | Princeton |
| 2002 | Daniel Klemetz | Middle Tennessee |
| 2001 | Marco Baron | Mississippi State |
| 2000 | Tom Hand | LSU |
| 1999 | Ryan Wolters | Stanford |
| 1998 | Paul Goldstein | Stanford |
| 1997 | Paul Goldstein | Stanford |
| 1996 | Jamie Laschinger | Georgia |
| 1995 | Mike Sprouse | Notre Dame |
| 1994 | Chris Pressley | Duke |
| 1993 | Chuck Coleman | Notre Dame |


